Gnus is an awesome mail and news reader, but it can be a bit of a performance bear, especially when using IMAP. Since Emacs is single-threaded, IMAP operations that take too long can disconnect you from IRC, Jabber, or any number of other network services you also use from Emacs.

The typical solution to this problem is to run Gnus in a dedicated Emacs instance. Doing so is really easy—just make a gnus shell alias like so:

alias gnus 'emacs -f gnus'

The catch is, such an Emacs doesn't know it's a dedicated, Gnus-only Emacs. When I used this technique, it was always confusing that quitting Gnus didn't quit its Emacs.

We can use command-switch-alist to define a custom -gnus command line argument that does what we want. Here's what I have in my .emacs file:

 '("gnus" . (lambda (&rest ignore)
              ;; Start Gnus when Emacs starts
              (add-hook 'emacs-startup-hook 'gnus t)
              ;; Exit Emacs after quitting Gnus
              (add-hook 'gnus-after-exiting-gnus-hook

To use the above, we just alter our shell alias to use our new argument:

alias gnus 'emacs -gnus'

The only other thing to keep in mind is how this sort of setup interacts with emacsclient. (This is a command that lets you edit files in an already-running Emacs.) I really only want emacsclient to open files in the other Emacs I have running, and not in my Gnus-only Emacs. Let's fix this by restricting when we start the server that emacsclient talks to.

(defvar ted-server-emacs t
  "If non-null, this emacs should run emacsclient.")

Now that we have a flag we can use, let's only call server-start when the flag's been raised:

(add-hook 'emacs-startup-hook
          (lambda ()
            (when ted-server-emacs

The only bit left to do is to (setq ted-server-emacs nil) inside the custom command line argument handler above.


  1. rpg

    This is an interesting discussion, but I was left wondering "what do you do about yanking?" I would have thought a big advantage of running gnus (the advantage I found when I used to use VM as my mail reader) is that it's easy to paste stuff from other emacs buffers into your messages. How do you do that here?

    Another question I was left with was "could the gnus-only emacs be made visually distinguishable?" This would keep you from mistakenly activating it when you want your primary emacs. I bet this could be done with color themes or something...

    rpg, 10 August 2010

  2. Hi rpg,

    Re: yanking, there are two sub-issues: inter-Emacs yanking, and intra-Emacs yanking. Which is to say, the Gnus-only Emacs is a full-fledged Emacs, so you can just open the file you want to yank from. If you want to copy from, say, ERC to Gnus, you M-w in the ERC Emacs and C-y in the Gnus Emacs.

    Re: distinguishing things visually, sure, you could easily run different color themes in them, or specify a different custom-file, or any number of other such distinctions.

    Edward O'Connor, 11 August 2010